Walking a tight rope, without a safety net

By Tuesday, February 28, 2017 2 No tags Permalink 4

Just ten months ago the government released its 2016 Budget. Amongst its many pages were the most far-reaching superannuation changes in a decade. But, where are we today?

Well, we have had an election that saw the government return by the very slimmest of margins, but most of the superannuation reforms have passed into law. In the most part, they are due to take effect from 1 July this year. That is in just four short months.

Most Australians, despite media hype to the contrary, will be largely unaffected to any significant degree.

One of the Budget reforms will see a reduction to the amounts we may contribute to super each year.

Yes, I agree that the reduction in the amount we can contribute will have an impact on some, however, we have come through relatively unscathed.

Often I hear people say that the government is wrong to restrict the amounts that can contribute to super – they should be encouraging us to contribute as much as possible.

Let me assure you that I fully appreciate this sentiment and people should be encouraged to save for their own retirement. After all, the objective of superannuation is to substitute or supplement the age pension.

However, there is a very fine balancing act going on here.

Super is taxed at very favourable rates. The maximum rate of tax a super fund pays is 15%.

But in many cases, a super fund pays no tax at all, particularly where a fund is paying pensions to members. Compare that to paying tax on income and investment earnings at your marginal tax rate where the rate can be as high as 49%. I know which tax rate I’d like to pay!

It is therefore a ‘no-brainer’ to understand that folk who are paying personal tax at a rate of 15% or more are likely to be attracted to super. And those on the higher tax rates are more likely to have the money available to make additional contributions to super.

We therefore have a situation where the individuals with the financial capacity to make large superannuation contributions are often those in the higher tax brackets. And they are keen to take advantage of the super tax rates. This, I think is where the mismatch between targeting tax concessions to those who need them most, and encouraging people to provide more for their own retirement, becomes reality.

The government is in a difficult position. It is like walking a tight rope across the Grand Canyon, without the safety net!

How does the government best target tax incentives to encourage the wider population to save more for retirement and, at the same time, limit the tax concessions available to the more wealthy?

The preferred, and perhaps simplest option is to restrict the amount that may be contributed to super.

Are the reduced contributions caps (limits) that come into effect on 1 July 2017 set at the right level? Only time will tell. Since the contributions caps, in their present form, were introduced from ten years ago, we have seen a lot of tweaking of the actual caps. Without a doubt, we will see more changes in the future.

The annual concessional and non-concessional contribution caps coming in on 1 July, whilst being more modest than those that currently apply, will generally be more than adequate for the majority of Australians wishing to save for their own retirement.

In fact, ignoring future increases in the new contributions caps, an individual with the capacity to pay, can still make net contributions of up to $1,412,500 over a ten-year period. And, if they are a couple, multiply that number by a factor of two!  The likelihood of most Australians being able to accumulate that level of superannuation savings over a lifetime of work, let along over just ten years, is highly desirable but, highly unlikely.

Even for the wealthy who have the capacity to make significant contributions, superannuation remains a very effective vehicle for accumulating savings for retirement and then managing the progressive drawing down of those savings in retirement.

Even though the goal posts have moved at little, with careful planning and some good advice, strategies exist that will enable significant savings to accumulate within the superannuation system.

And, for those readers looking for opportunities before the 30 June 2017, consider making concessional and non-concessional contributions under the current, more generous caps. However, if seeking to make large contributions, seek professional advice before making a contribution.

We would love to hear your thoughts in the comments section below.

 

 

4
2 Comments
  • Jan Wild
    March 2, 2017

    There is an alternative to restricting contributions and that is to tax pension payments on their way out of super. If taxed at PAYG marginal rates it would be entirely equitable.
    On a different subject, why do all the comments I make seem to disappear off your site?

    • Peter Kelly
      April 10, 2017

      Jan,

      I am not sure why your comments from other posts are being deleted. That is certainly not our policy. We are currently investigating this.

      If you would like to email me directly, and let me know what posts you have commented on, I can look into this more closely. My email address is Peter.Kelly@cpal.com.au

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


 

The information contained within this website is provided in good faith. Any information is provided as a general guide only and does not take into account the objectives, financial situation or needs of any individual. Accordingly before acting on any advice or information contained within this website you should consider the appropriateness having regard to your specific individual objectives, financial situation and/or needs. Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, no liability shall be assumed on any ground whatsoever with respect to decisions or actions taken as a result of acting upon such information. We strongly recommend that independent professional advice be obtained and additionally a copy of any relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision about whether to acquire a particular financial product.